← All writing

,

Swim Upstream: How AI Animation Actually Gets Made

A filmmaker in Helsinki asked me how AI animation actually gets made. The answer is context, taste and a long fussy toolchain. Plus seven people I told him to call.

Futureproof Festival of AI artwork: schools of orange and gold fish swim through swirling blue water around the words Swim Upstream, with ferns, mushrooms and the BC + AI Ecosystem logo.

This morning a filmmaker in Helsinki asked me how AI animation actually gets made. He wanted the mess. I’ve been waiting two years for somebody to want the mess.

Harley trained as an animator, wandered the planet for a while, landed in Finland, and is now writing a master’s thesis at Arcada on what generative AI is doing to production pipelines in animation, VFX and film. I was his first interview. We booked thirty minutes and blew straight through it.

I’m writing it up while it’s warm, because every answer I gave him came out of a room. A Film Club night in Gastown. A Zoom full of animators learning to direct machines. A stage at Futureproof two weeks ago, where Kevin Friel stood under two words the size of a billboard.

Kevin Friel holds a microphone on stage beneath the projected words Green Light Yourself, with the audience in the foreground.
Kevin Friel at Futureproof Festival of AI, October 30, 2026. Photo: Michelle Diamond / Diamond’s Edge Photography.

GREEN LIGHT YOURSELF. Hold that thought. First I have to kill a different green thing.

Nobody presses the green button

There’s a fantasy about this work, and it’s shared by the people who love AI and the people who hate it. You type a sentence. You press a big green button. A movie falls out.

The button exists. I told Harley as much. You can hand one of the new video models a prompt and get back minutes of footage with camera cuts, voices, sound effects and a score. This summer five frontier models landed inside two weeks and four of them were open source. It’s bananas out there.

Nobody I respect works that way.

They use those one-shot generations the way a carpenter uses a 2×4. It’s a part. The real thing is still a long, fussy toolchain: storyboards, concepts, character development, scripts, pre-production, assets, production, post. Every one of those stages now has its own stack of tools, generative and otherwise. Midjourney and Photoshop. Seedance, Kling and Veo. ElevenLabs for sound. DaVinci Resolve for the cut. Local rigs with GPUs humming under the desk, right next to a dozen subscriptions.

I joke that it costs two grand a month to equip yourself as a modern media maker. Harley laughed. Then he wrote it down.

We’ve been saying this in Vancouver for a while. When we wrote up the animation accelerator for BC + AI, the headline was the prompt era is over, learn to direct. Nobody leaves that class thinking you type a sentence and get a cartoon.

Eighty percent of the job happens before I make anything

Harley’s first real question: what’s taking up most of your head right now?

Context. That’s the answer. I’d put it at 80% of my creative work these days, and none of it looks like creating.

Here’s a real one. Say I’m building a keynote about what’s happening to animation. Before a single slide exists, I’ve got agents in Claude Code out researching the disruption three ways: for studios, for audiences, for the individual artist. Each one comes back as a dossier. Then I drop in the transcript from our last Film Club, because that’s people living it, in their own words. Then two or three minutes of me rambling into a mic about what I think the talk is. Last, the boring specs. Vertical. Sixty seconds. These logos. This brand guide.

Now make the first draft.

I call those piles silos of context. Research, community voice, my voice and the constraints, sitting in one place where a model can reach them. One pile becomes a keynote, a blog post, a clip and next month’s meetup slides. I’ve written about pieces of this before, in the keynote slides workflow, in the agentic workflows guide, and in what I showed a room of founders in September.

Kevin Friel gave a whole Film Club talk on this in April and named it better than I did.

Kevin Friel, Context Is the New Art Form. BC + AI Film Club, April 2026.

Animation runs on the same physics. In the AI Animation and Filmmaking Accelerator we run with Tiny Ghost Studios, the first two thirds of the work is script, character sheets and camera moves. Students show up wanting to generate. We make them write.

And when a shot goes sideways, you can’t prompt your way out. I call that brute force prompting and it has never once saved me. You go back upstream. Fix the script. Fix the character reference. Then generate again.

Talk first. Type later.

Where does the story come from? Your mouth.

Your fingers are a filter between your head, your heart and the machine. When people type a prompt they tidy themselves up. When they talk, the mess stays in, and the mess is where the person lives. So we start the accelerator with voice. Record yourself telling the story. Transcribe it. Build from there.

I’ve got a whole piece on this, Speak It Into Existence, and I’ll keep banging the drum until somebody takes my keyboard away.

From the voice you get characters. From characters you get to Midjourney, and this is the slot machine part. Pull the lever. Pull it again. Make a thousand things. But you’re pulling it inside your script and your character notes, and you’re hunting for the one image that feels like yours.

Then comes the wall every AI filmmaker has smashed into: consistency. Making one cool thing is easy now. Making the same character, in the same world, lit the same way, across ninety seconds? That’s been the whole fight. The newer reference tools hold the character, the environment and the style together across a longer piece. A year ago it was the first thing you’d spot in an AI short at a festival. It’s getting harder to spot.

The pros are hybrid

Harley asked how many tools end up in a real workflow. I hummed and hawed, because the honest answer is: a stupid number.

But here’s the cleanest line I can draw between hobbyists and professionals. Hobbyists take what the machine gives them. Pros treat it as raw material.

  • They pick one character out of a thousand Midjourney rolls, drag it into Photoshop, fix it by hand, and feed that back in as the reference.
  • They generate a music track, then split it into stems and keep one vocal line or one strange texture. Nobody’s dropping the whole generated anthem on the timeline.
  • They generate video, then cut it the old-fashioned way.

Text, then the human hand. Images, then the human hand. Video, then the human hand.

Mayumi Rollings, who co-founded Tiny Ghost and teaches the accelerator, says flat out that AI is never going to replace taste, and that her studio does a heavy amount of Photoshop and manual work on everything. Magenta Rúne, her partner there, told our very first Film Club what the trade actually buys you:

There’s the 20% creative and the 80% grind. With AI now, it’s flipped.

Magenta Rúne, BC + AI Film Club, January 2026
Magenta Rúne on recapturing the art school dream. BC + AI Film Club launch night, January 2026.

There’s also a new layer of studio tools that wrap the whole pipeline: script, storyboard, character sheets, and a line out to every major model, in one interface. ComfyUI is the one everybody knows. Multimodal Media Lab in Gastown, where Film Club lives, is building its own.

An artist is what they throw away

Then Harley asked the money question. How do you stop burning credits on stuff you can’t use?

I don’t know that you do. I’m not sure you should want to.

I think an artist is defined by what they don’t show. Every piece of work that’s ever flattened me had a mountain of rejected versions underneath it. So I gave Harley a choice. I’ve got two tickets. One’s for a film by a brilliant prompter who nailed it in one shot. The other’s for a film by somebody who made a hundred and can tell you why this is the one. Which do you take?

He took the second. Everybody does.

This is the thing I can’t stop writing about. Your taste is your moat. Make culture, not content. Generation is cheap. Taste is not. I told a room at Electronic Arts that DJs used to be called selectors, and that’s the job now. It’s also a whole section of the Punk Rock AI talk I gave at CreativeMornings in May.

Punk Rock AI at CreativeMornings Vancouver, May 2026. Cued to The Selector. More at punkrockai.com.

Dorothy Pang said the same thing from our meetup stage in July, and she has the hardware to back it up. Do it a thousand times, she told the room, ten thousand times, and your images just get better. And then:

It is still human vision driving it that makes it shine.

Dorothy Pang, Vancouver AI Meetup #31, July 2026

Two practical habits fall out of all this.

Organize before you generate. My creative courses start in Notion, which surprises people. You’re about to make a pile of rad shit. Know where it is, what prompt made it and how you got there. The little animations I make for Film Club every month are built from stills I generated two years ago, back when I was first learning Midjourney.

Feed new models your failures. Everybody’s got a folder of abandoned projects. When a fancy new model drops, don’t ask it for something new. Point it at the wreckage. Here’s every asset from a 30-second short I never finished. Figure it out. Make me a first draft. Best model test I know.

I AM NOMAD, the short Suzy Easton and I made for a Film Club prompt challenge. Nine cuts, one melting whale.

Learn the plumbing

If you made me bet on one skill with shelf life, I’d bet on ComfyUI.

You build your own pipeline out of nodes. You own it. Some new model drops out of the sky next Tuesday and embarrasses everything before it? Plug it in. Run the pipeline again. Everything you learned still counts.

Everything talks to everything now, through APIs and MCP. Image models, audio models, video models, all wired into one graph. Every serious person I know has it in their stack, whether they make immersive art, experiential video or straight animation. Kevin said it at Film Club in August: the models come and go, the hardware changes, and Comfy is what ties it all together. At Futureproof somebody asked him about controls, and his answer was about repeatability. When a client loves a shot and wants one small change, you’d better know which decision made the thing they love.

The tech works. The industry doesn’t.

Harley asked where it breaks down. I think he expected me to say character consistency, or lip sync.

It’s people. It’s the business.

Animation isn’t dying. It’s exploding. What’s at risk is some studios as they’re currently built and some jobs as they currently exist. And the industry is handling that about as gracefully as you’d expect.

We get people from the biggest animation studios in this town registering for our workshops with their personal Gmail accounts. They don’t want anybody at work to know. Sit with that for a second. The same companies are using this stuff in production and keeping quiet about it. Magenta said it on Film Club’s first night: big names, quietly moving in. There’s a shadow economy running under the official one.

Meanwhile the unions are in the street, and they should be. I photographed this in May.

A Canadian Animation Guild banner carried at a Vancouver protest march.
The Canadian Animation Guild at the data centre march in Vancouver, May 23, 2026. From Both Hands Full at the Data Center. Photo: Kris Krüg.

So you’ve got artists who are curious and scared, studios that are adopting and denying, and a union movement fighting for a seat at a table that keeps getting moved. Stigma on one side, secrecy on the other. That’s the breakdown. No model release fixes it.

I’ve got both hands full on this one, same as always. I wrote We Trained AI On Stolen Work. I Am More Creative Than Ever. and Artists Learn. Machines Extract. inside the same two months, and I meant every word of both. A professional class of illustrators and animators is worth protecting. So is the explosion. The hard work is refusing to drop either one.

Advice for a twenty-two-year-old with a reel

Harley’s thesis has a junior-senior thread, so he asked what I’d have a new grad do for their first six months.

I’ve been chewing on this one. Nobody got into animation because they dreamed of being a compositor. They got in because they loved drawing and stories. Then the industry handed them a seat on a 300-person crew doing explosions for eighteen months.

That ladder was built for a factory. The factory is wobbling. I don’t have the junior pipeline problem solved. Nobody does.

So go the other way. Make whole things, by yourself, start to finish. See how far one person can get.

Here’s the dare I’ve given myself. If AI makes everything that used to be my job easy, the job has to get bigger. Forget squeezing a one-year animation into four weeks. What would you make if you gave yourself the whole year and the machines?

And know this about the machines: they trend toward the median. Always. Your weird little Venn diagram is the one thing they’re unlikely to output. The records you grew up on, the cartoons that wrecked you, the way you see the world. Learn to name your influences and say why you love them.

Then shove your humanity into every crack you can find. Draw every day. Scan the drawings. Make your titles with markers, shoot them on your phone, and have the model work in that style. I play trumpet. I record it, pull it into ElevenLabs, and remix the pieces. Handmade and endlessly iterable. I can’t think of anything I couldn’t make that way.

Grub’s Cantina by Jennifer Li, a student film from the accelerator. More in the student film series.

Green light yourself

Which brings me back to Kevin and the billboard.

His Futureproof talk was about a film idea called Shepherds that he’d carried around for years. He’s a 25-year VFX guy. He’s shipped real work for real money. And he still described his finger hovering over the post button with his heart going.

Then he told a story about fumbling somebody’s Film Club submission. First slide: I fumbled a file. Next slide: No, I fumbled a person. I wrote more about it in the festival proceedings, because it’s the best organizing advice I heard all year, smuggled inside a filmmaking talk.

Kevin Friel speaks beside a colourful BC + AI Film Club projection of cartoon buildings and film cameras.
The Film Club story on the festival screen. October 30, 2026. Photo: Michelle Diamond / Diamond’s Edge Photography.

That’s the real answer to the green button. Nobody’s coming to green light you. There’s never been less standing between a person and a finished piece of media. People are mocking up half-baked concepts with these tools and using them to get the real version funded. The door’s open. You still have to walk through it with something that sounds like you.

Harley asked if I had a line I live by. I blanked, and then I remembered the shirts.

When I was a kid, the man who ran my school ended every rally the same way. Any dead fish can float down the stream, but it takes a live fish to swim against the current. I’m pretty sure he meant obedience. I heard permission. Thirty-odd years later I just printed a batch of shirts that say SWIM UPSTREAM, and the line’s in the Punk Rock AI talk too.

There’s a lot of shit being pushed downstream at us right now. Harley told me he says the same thing to his brother. I knew I liked that guy.


Seven people I told him to call

Before we hung up, Harley asked for four more people to interview. I got excited and sent seven. Animators, VFX, immersive, academics, a high school teacher. All friendlies. All different. If you’re researching this stuff, here’s the list, with my reasons.

Kevin Friel

Mr. Pixel Wizard. Twenty-five years of traditional VFX and filmmaking, and the host of BC + AI Film Club since night one. He runs the prompt challenge that’s pulled around ninety short films out of this community in 2026. Toilet paper ads. Zombies. Space opera. Old gods in a new world. He’ll tell you which models matter this month, and then he’ll tell you to show your work while it’s still broken. LinkedIn · kevinfriel.com · In the Room · and for old times’ sake, the first thing I ever wrote about him

Dorothy Pang

Kevin introduced her at our July meetup as the most modest rock star you’ll ever meet. Visual artist, AI filmmaker, creative director. An ADC Bronze Cube in AI Visual Design for Love Hotel, and a spot on Leonardo.Ai’s 2026 Top 50 Women AI Filmmakers. Her line that the agentic film tools still lack soul, and that you have to put the humanity in at the script, is the whole argument of this post in one breath. dorothypang.org · LinkedIn

Dorothy Pang on art direction and creativity in AI filmmaking. Vancouver AI Meetup #31, July 2026.

Michael Tippett

Tippett and I go back twenty years. He started NowPublic, the citizen journalism network, before most people had a camera phone. Now he runs Generation Studios, makes an agentic-crime noir micro-series called West Side City, and keeps tippa.org, a directory of 700-plus AI films, so that work lands with people better at it than him. His words. He won a Squatchie from us last December for it. LinkedIn

Video is the future of communication, and AI is the future of video.

Michael Tippett, BC + AI Film Club, January 2026

Yangos Hadjiyiannis

Experience Director at Multimodal Media Lab, the Gastown studio at 375 Water Street that hosts Film Club every month. Two decades and more than 250 immersive projects, including the official virtual world of the Cannes XR festival. MML is a research lab, a school and an original-IP shop under one roof, and they’re building the kind of all-in-one studio tool I described up top. He also built our film submissions portal, which after Kevin’s talk I will never again call a small thing. LinkedIn · BC + AI profile

Patrick Pennefather

Associate professor at UBC in theatre, film and media studies, and faculty in residence at the Emerging Media Lab. Patrick, David Gaertner and I co-wrote a peer-reviewed paper about this community for BC Studies. He also once got a room full of AI people to sing a Christmas carol about surveillance. For a thesis writer he’s the jackpot: somebody who can tell you what’s happening and cite it. patrickpennefather.com · LinkedIn · In the Room

Magenta Rúne

Chief Amazement Officer at Tiny Ghost Studios, which is a real title and I’m jealous. Decades in games, TV and film, now making an original series called Blood and Glitter and teaching the accelerator with Mayumi. Magenta teaches the same workflow the studio uses on paid client work, which is rarer than it should be. LinkedIn · In the Room

Magenta Rúne and Mayumi Rollings of Tiny Ghost Studios on AI animation and filmmaking.

Brad Necyk

Visual artist, AI filmmaker, PhD. His doctorate is research-creation in psychiatry, and it won the Governor General’s Gold Medal. He made the Psychedelic Puppet Show, runs the A Position on Retreat residency on Vancouver Island, and teaches digital literacy at Shawnigan Lake School, so he’s watching teenagers meet these tools in real time.

Brad Necyk speaks beside a projected abstract artwork of blue and red forms on a white field.
Brad Necyk, AI and Imagination, Futureproof Festival of AI, October 29, 2026. Artwork: Brad Necyk. Photo: Michelle Diamond / Diamond’s Edge Photography.

At Futureproof he talked about speaking half-formed, contradictory ideas into a model before the sensible sentence shows up to tidy them away. A cathedral made of weather. His point, which I can’t shake: the person writing the second prompt isn’t quite the person who wrote the first. The work changes you, and then you ask for something different. My writeup is here. bradnecyk.com · LinkedIn


If you want an intro to any of them, email me. I told Harley the same thing I’ll tell you: I will forget, so nudge me, one name per email, and I’ll forward it on.

He’s aiming to publish in February. I asked for the transcript and a look at the drafts, and I told him that if he makes it to Canada next year he should bring the research to Film Club and present it.

That goes for you too. Film Club is the second Thursday of every month at 375 Water Street. The next one is December 10. Bring a rough cut. Bring the thing you never finished.

We’ll make sure the file plays.