At Vancouver city hall, I asked for careful assessment of AI data centres and a practical public benefit: access to the machines themselves.
Vancouver, November 18, 2026.
I spend a lot of time helping people figure out what AI can do. This afternoon I went to city hall to talk about what we owe each other when we build it.
I was the second registered speaker on Motion 10, Addressing the Risks of Digital Infrastructure, brought by Councillor Lucy Maloney. I asked council to pass it, and to include public access to computing in the study of benefits from data centres.
The motion passed unanimously this afternoon. I’ll add the posted decision here when it is available, including the final wording of any amendments.
A data centre becomes part of a neighbourhood. People will live beside its equipment and share the infrastructure it depends on. They deserve to know what is proposed, what it will consume, and who can be held to the promises.
I want useful AI infrastructure here. We should be able to explain the decision to the people who will live beside it.
Two questions for the next proposal
I run BC + AI. We help people learn these tools, build with them, and argue about what they should be used for. My own position includes an uncomfortable fact: many of the models were trained on creative work without consent, and they have made me more creative and productive than I have ever been.
I’ve written about holding those two truths at once. At the microphone today, I put them beside two questions:
Is the harm acceptable, and does the public share in the returns?
Water use, electricity, noise, heat and employment can be examined. A neighbour should be able to read the assessment and ask how a number was reached. A promise should come with someone responsible for keeping it.
The submitted motion asks staff to report back on independent impact assessments, climate consistency, noise protections, enforceable commitments and annual public disclosure. It includes a review of 175 West Cordova and similar retrofits. It seeks a framework ahead of further approvals. Those requirements still have to be developed.
The municipal decisions and open questions are collected in the BC + AI Vancouver Civic AI Voter Guide. Today’s digital-infrastructure motion is its own agenda item, separate from the omnibus motion at the same meeting.

I photographed the protests too. In Both Hands on the Power Cord, I followed the electricity into the questions about ownership and access.
A library card for compute
Clause F asks staff to explore how the public could benefit from data centres. I offered an idea for the study: make some of the computing available to people doing useful work here.
GPU hours are time on the processors that run AI models. Could students, researchers, nonprofits, startups and Indigenous-led projects get access, with support to use it? What would it cost? Who would decide? How would we know whether the access was actually delivered?
The Economy of Wisdom Foundation’s Compute Community Centre proposal gives that discussion a budget to examine. The whole-building plan combines 48 public terminals, 19 GPU nodes and 12 homes. The published capital estimate is about $24.81 million CAD. That is a proposal to scrutinize, with a site still to find and funding still to secure. Today’s vote did not approve or fund it.
The library model matters. You could walk in with a question before you had a company, a cloud budget or a pitch deck. Public access would mean machines, people to help you use them, and a way to keep both available. A line in a developer’s brochure would not be enough.

At Futureproof Festival, Sev Geraskin brought the infrastructure question down to the people who keep it working. My recap of his October 29 session follows that argument into his community-compute proposal. Someone has to maintain the machines, help people use them and answer when something breaks. Those people belong in the budget too.

I also pointed council to Internet Archive Canada, a Canadian digital library operating since 2006. It is an example of computing infrastructure serving a public purpose. Archival storage and AI computing have different power and cooling demands; an AI proposal still has to account for its own impacts.
For people who want to start smaller, BC + AI hosts Jeremy Bayley’s free Train Your Own AI Models handbook and Local AI Fundamentals. Access needs someone who can help you use the thing. That support has to be paid for.
Asking questions is part of building
Rob Goehring, CEO of WISR AI, described some AI discussion as a “Terminator narrative” in Canada’s National Observer on July 17. He pointed to advances in medicine, materials, biotech and software that he felt were getting too little attention.
Those advances deserve attention. They do not tell us how much water a particular building will use, what its neighbours will hear at night, or what residents get in return. Moving from a question about a proposed facility to a list of AI’s achievements leaves the original question sitting there, unanswered.
If an impact assessment is a Terminator narrative, so is a building permit.
This week, in the Vancouver Sun, Goehring offered several possible reasons for TELUS leaving its local projects. He said he had “no inside information.” Among the possibilities, he described the new mayor and council as “not fans of AI data centres.”
Fans? We are choosing terms for infrastructure. Council should be able to ask for evidence without having its enthusiasm graded. I would rather hear an answer about water, power, noise and public access than a diagnosis of whether the people asking are sufficiently excited.
I build with AI and teach people to use it. I want its benefits here. That is why I want the proposal specific enough to inspect, the promises specific enough to enforce, and the public benefit specific enough to use. Show us the numbers. Then we can have a useful argument.
Our recorded AI and Climate Impact panel gets into those questions too. The November 2025 discussion includes a water-justice and data-centre chapter at 25:19.
The AI Ethical Futures Lab has been doing the slower work too. Its March 2026 discussion took up the questions left by the federal AI sprint. This summer, Peter Van Garderen prepared the questions and Sara Taherzadeh wrote the submission that became the Lab’s September transparency response.
The submission asks for a visible connection between what people say and what government does next. That is a useful standard to bring back to city hall.
What I said at council
Here is the City of Vancouver’s November 18 recording. It covers the full committee meeting; my remarks are on Motion 10. The City’s indexed player provides another route through the meeting.
The remarks below have filler and obvious transcription errors cleaned up.
Read my delivered remarks
Chair, councillors, mayor. My name is Kris Krüg. I am a Vancouver resident and I’m the executive director of BC + AI, a non-profit grassroots community with 300 members that is building with AI, working on AI safety and debating about where technology is taking us.
Where I stand is two things at once. Many of these models were trained on the creative work of humanity without consent, and they have made me more creative and productive than I’ve ever been in my career. Both of these things are true. I come to this with both hands full, curiosity in one hand and critique in the other.
People’s concerns here are legitimate. Power, water, noise, work used without asking. So are the possibilities: new skills, new companies, and new science. Please set terms that let both be true, with two tests. Is the harm acceptable, and does the public share in the returns?
People will need somewhere to get their AI tokens from, and today that compute mostly comes from elsewhere, on someone else’s terms. The Silicon Valley hyperscaler neo-cloud business model of rolling out AI is not the only way. Vancouver can and should invest in local AI: clean, green, just compute infrastructure that brings everyone along.
Our organization is working towards a federal West Coast AI Centre of Excellence, like the Mila Institute in Montreal, like the Vector Institute in Toronto, and like the Alberta Machine Intelligence Institute in Edmonton. This is ongoing work, and I invite you to learn more about it, and support the initiative, and get involved.
This motion asks city staff to design good terms: independent impact assessments before approvals, annual public disclosures of water, power, and noise, and a real public benefit, so that wealth built on our grid and our land flows back to residents. Not just goodwill, but a concrete return that people can point to.
On clause F of Councillor Maloney’s motion, one idea for the study: benefits can be more than just fees collected. It can be the compute itself. GPU hours for students, for research, for nonprofits, for startups, and for Indigenous-led projects.
Vancouver’s Economy of Wisdom Foundation has published a line-by-line costing for one: a public compute commons built on the library model. Please ask staff to include options like these.
The city already hosts public benefit digital infrastructure like the Internet Archive, an independent Canadian digital library running since 2006, headquartered downtown on West Pender, preserving Canadian digital memory on Canadian soil. Over a million Canadian items, 30 years of the internet in Canada.
The way to gain social license for clean, green, just AI infrastructure is in front of you. Assessment, disclosure, and public benefit that people can point to. Please pass this motion and make the benefits real. Thank you.
The West Coast centre I mentioned is an ambition we are working toward, not an announced federal designation.
After the microphone
The vote sends the work to staff. I’ll be looking for the assessments people can inspect, the obligations that can be enforced, and the public-benefit options under clause F.
We’ll keep the conversation going at the November 25 Vancouver AI meetup. Bring what you’re building and the question you have not figured out yet.
Before the next permit is signed, we should be able to explain to a neighbour what will change, what protections they have, and who will pick up the phone.
Follow the paper trail
The motion, proposed amendment and meeting
- Motion 10: Addressing the Risks of Digital Infrastructure, submitted text (PDF). The original clauses A–G, including the public-benefit study in clause F.
- November 18 committee agenda. Motion 10 is listed separately from Motion 12, the omnibus motion.
- Official indexed meeting video and the City’s YouTube recording. A proposed clause H appeared on screen, asking staff to report back on a separate use definition for AI data centres and general bulk data storage. I have not verified its adoption against a posted final decision.
- Council agendas, minutes and decisions. The place to check the final adopted wording when the City posts it. The submitted PDF above is not an amended final text.
From today’s council debate
- Sitka Media, November 18: my council remarks on public benefit from AI data centres. A clip of my remarks about local computing infrastructure and making sure residents share in the returns.
Reporting and wider context
These pieces provide background to today’s vote. They were published before it.
- Daily Hive, November 14: TELUS leaves the two Vancouver projects; Westbank says it will proceed with a new partner. Includes both companies’ statements and explains that Motion 10 requests further policy work.
- Vancouver Sun: TELUS and Westbank end their data-centre partnership. The source for Goehring’s comments this week, including his caveat about having no inside information.
- Data Center Dynamics, November 16: TELUS withdraws from the Vancouver development plans. Trade-press coverage of the partnership change.
- The Tyee, September 29: BC’s local governments call for higher taxes for AI data centres. The wider debate over property classification and municipal costs.
- Canada’s National Observer, July 17: the earlier Vancouver data-centre debate. The source of the July “Terminator narrative” quotation discussed above.
A public-compute option to examine
- Economy of Wisdom: Compute Community Centre proposal and costing. The published assumptions behind the proposal, including capital and operating costs.
- Sev Geraskin’s Futureproof session, slides and recap. The source of the original diagram reproduced above.




